Interesting Polemic letter regarding the practice of circumcising a child born to a non Jewish mother.

London & Cardiff, 1943.

Front side with a short & to the point letter by the Gaon Rabbi Yechezkel Abramsky 

"I will update you kindly. I hereby inform you that a ruling has been issued from our court stating that it is forbidden to circumcise a son born to a Jew from a non-Jewish mother, and the mohalim in London refrain from circumcising him.


Blessings and best wishes".


Reverse side with the reply of the Gaon Rabbi Moshe Eliyahu Rogosnitzky ”

"Honorable Rabbi, may he live long!


Please accept back the ”ruling” that has come from your court, as I do not know what it is or what it pertains to. I do not need the directives of your court and find it intrusive. This is the second time you send it to me without my request. I have never seen or heard of such a strange conduct. Perhaps there is a misunderstanding or an error that can be repealed


With esteem and respect."

The Gaon Rabbi Yechezkel Abramsky [1886-1976] studied in his youth at the Novardok Yeshiva where he was close to the "Alter of Novardok" and at his request he even studied with his sons. At the age of 17 he was ordained by the city’s rabbi, Rabbi Yechiel Michel Epstein, author of Aruch Ha-Shulchan. He then studied at the Telz Yeshiva. He also studied at the Ramiles Yeshiva and in the "Kibbutz" of Rabbi Chaim Ozer Grodzinski in Vilna, and under Rabbi Chaim of Brisk.

He served as Rabbi of Slutsk, Smalian and Smolbichi. In 1923, in Slutsk he replaced Rabbi Isser Zalman Meltzer, who had to flee because of persecution by the Communist regime. In 1925 published the first part of his commentary on the Tosefta. At the beginning of the winter of 1932 he settled in London and began serving as rabbi of the Machzikei Hadat congregation, and in 1933 he was appointed Dayan at the Rabbinical Court in London and two years later as head of the city’s rabbinical court. During these years he continued with his great enterprise – the interpretation of the Tosefta – "Chazon Yehezkel". In 1951, he immigrated to Israel with his family and settled in the Beit Vagan neighborhood in Jerusalem, In it he continued his work and spreading his teachings. author of Chazon Yechezkel on the Tosefta & many other works.

The Gaon Rabbi Moshe Eliyahu Rogosnitzky, son of Rabbi Leib of Nalibok (Lithuania) and leading disciple of Rabbi Zalman sender Cahana – Shapira of Krinik. Dayan and Rosh Yeshiva in Leipzig. Rabbi of Cardiff, Wales.


12 X 20.5 Cm.

Share this lot:

Lot #208

Interesting Polemic letter concerning circumcising a child from a non Jewish mother, by the Gaonim Rabbi Yechezkel Abramsky Ravad London & Rabbi Moshe Eliyahu Rogosnitzky rabbi of Cardiff. 1943

Start price: $400

Sales Tax: On the lot's price and buyer's premium

Offcanvas right